The story begins at the moment just after the nation’s founding, with an artist who was one of the principal recorders of that tumultuous period.
In 1802, a group of politicians and society elite formed an institution with the goal of training more American artists in the classical style. They called it The New York Academy of Fine Arts. The Academy had a slow start, mostly languishing until 1817, when John Trumbull became its president. Trumbull was one of the most prolific and respected artists during the time of the American Revolution, having had the likes of George Washington, Alexander Hamilton, and many others sit for him multiple times.
The Academy’s mission was to help prove to the world that this rebellious cohort at the edge of the vast continent was worthy of nationhood. Their method was to give American artists exposure to great European works which they could emulate, enabling them to produce a body of work for this nascent nation that could stand alongside the art treasures of the old world. With such a lofty mission the name was soon changed to The American Academy of Fine Arts.
But after several years, many of the Academy’s students grew dissatisfied with the quality of instruction and with Trumbull’s autocratic leadership style. They felt the need to break away and form a new group. Here was the supreme irony: Trumbull had been the visual chronicler for the rebellious patriots who dared break away from the established order of the world, creating a new society by rejecting nobility and monarchy. Yet he was unable to adapt his own methods; he was unwilling to share artistic authority. So, like the Patriots Trumbull had immortalized in paint, his students felt compelled to rebel—against him.
This new group, calling themselves the National Academy of Design, was determined to foster new talent and produce more artists. The National Academy’s founders—Thomas Cole, Asher Durand, Samuel Morse, and others—set into motion what would become this nation’s longest-running arts organization. The National Academy of Design was formed in 1825 and continues today. While their headquarters are now on West 26th Street, the Academy’s most prominent location was just a short walk from here, on 23rd Street and Park Avenue South, in a building modeled after the Doge’s Palace in Venice.
The National Academy of Design’s operational structure, like the American Academy’s, was modeled after the Royal Academy of Arts in London, which itself drew from the French Royal Academy established in 1648. By now, this had become the standard European model: a select few society elites serving on juries would act as arbiters of taste, determining which artists would be featured each season. These juries, composed of small numbers of influential figures and often motivated by personal relationships or grievances, would decide for the public what was acceptable, making or destroying artists’ careers often by mood or whim. Many considered the salons and academies too rigid and unaccepting of new techniques and styles.
In 1892, Scottish immigrant William Macbeth opened a gallery at 237 Fifth Avenue (between 27th and 28th Streets), which was the first dedicated to the continuous exhibition of American artists. Prior to this, galleries would showcase American artists occasionally throughout the year, but their mainstay—what they knew would draw the biggest crowds owing to prevailing notions of cultural prestige—remained the European masters. When Macbeth Gallery opened, more than a century after the ratification of the U.S. Constitution, for the first time there was a space the American public could walk into at any time and see their own country’s contribution to the art world.
In 1908, Macbeth Gallery would break convention again. An exhibition that year showcased eight artists who had not been validated by The National Academy of Design. That once-rebellious institution was now seen as too rigid and conservative. William Macbeth was approached by artist Robert Henri who had just resigned from the Academy’s jury in protest of their rejection of the artists. Newspaper headlines noted the break from the Academy and proclaimed that there would be an art show on Fifth Avenue—the epicenter of high society—where none of the artists had been vetted by a jury. Finally, there would be an exhibit where the public could see the works of local artists and would be able to judge the art for themselves.
Those breakaway artists, known as “The Eight,” included Robert Henri, William Glackens, George Luks, Everett Shinn, John Sloan, Arthur B. Davies, Ernest Lawson, and Maurice Prendergast. As The New York Times noted, they “were united by a shared distaste for the prevailing academicism in American art and an embrace of modern, socially engaged themes of urban realism.” Five of these artists—Henri, Glackens, Luks, Shinn, and Sloan—became associated with what was later called the Ashcan School, an art movement perfectly suited to New York City during a period Mark Twain dubbed “The Gilded Age”—a term connoting a society with a thin veneer of gold covering a rough core of wrought iron. The Ashcan artists used dark colors and bold brushwork to convey gritty scenes of urban life experienced by much of the population in America’s rapidly growing cities.
Macbeth Gallery played an important role in societal change yet again in 1915 when it hosted the newly formed New York Society for Women Artists for an “Exhibition of Painting and Sculpture by Women Artists for the Benefit of the Woman Suffrage Campaign.” By that time, several states had granted women voting rights, and in 1915, four more states, including New York, were targeted by the suffragist movement. The issue was placed on the November ballot and numerous events were planned throughout the year to convince men to vote for equal suffrage. To help further this initiative the exhibit at Macbeth Gallery showcased women’s contributions to the nation’s artistic heritage.
At the same time that Macbeth Gallery was knocking down barriers for American artists another gallery at 30th Street and Fifth Avenue was helping to elevate a new technology to a level of true artistic appreciation. “291” galleries opened at 291 Fifth Avenue (30th Street) in 1905 by photographer Alfred Stieglitz with an aim to spread appreciation of fine art photography. Early photography was a crude record of a moment that lacked the bold color and imagination of fine art painting. The act of recording light must have felt like a momentous scientific accomplishment but the actual photographs — lacking color and depth — must have seemed like a dull, believe it or not, unrealistic representation of a scene. Furthermore photography was not respected as art at all because it was done by a machine that anyone could buy and so it was assumed that creative skill was not a part of the medium. So, while the Ashcan school sought to strip away from painting any gratuitous, or even interesting, expressions of color — using not only paint but black ink in order to convey the dirty, arduous reality of urban life during the industrial age — Stieglitz, understanding the medium’s artistic potential when the technology was still new, wanted to elevate photography so that it would be accepted as a fine art.
Reflecting Stieglitz’s rebellious stance and break from convention, 291 was originally known as the Little Galleries of the Photo-Secession. In 1907 291 hosted the first exhibit of autochrome (color) prints in the United States. Stieglitz then used his deep art-world connections to secure works of painting, sculpture, and print by avant-garde European modern artists who were not yet accepted by high society on either side of the Atlantic. With its continuous exhibitions of fine-art photography and innovative artists in several forms 291 garnered a reputation as a host to cutting-edge works unavailable anywhere else. This led to a remarkable string of firsts including the first showing of Rodin’s late pencil and watercolor figure drawings, the first exhibition of Matisse’s work ever held in the United States, the first U.S. solo exhibition of Cézanne, the first U.S. solo exhibition of Picasso and the world’s first exhibition of Matisse’s sculpture. As the gallery evolved, Stieglitz increasingly focused on American modernists, providing crucial early support to artists who would become central figures in American art history. These included John Marin, Marsden Hartley, Arthur Dove, and perhaps most significantly, Georgia O’Keeffe. Initially, Stieglitz displayed O’Keeffe’s drawings in a 291 group show in 1916, then in a one-person presentation the following year. O’Keeffe would later become Stieglitz’s wife and develop into one of America’s most celebrated artists.
The Ultimate Rebellion: The 1913 Armory Show
The pattern of institutionalization and rebellion that had defined American art for over a century reached its crescendo just blocks from Macbeth Gallery, in an event so revolutionary it would forever alter the course of American culture. Fittingly, it was Arthur B. Davies—one of “The Eight” who had rebelled against the National Academy of Design—who would lead the most radical artistic uprising in American history.
By 1911, even “The Eight” had begun to feel constrained by American artistic conventions. Davies and several colleagues formed the Association of American Painters and Sculptors, initially planning a modest exhibition of representational American works. But Davies harbored grander ambitions. If American art was ever to break free from European dominance, Americans needed to see what the European avant-garde was actually creating—not the safe, academic European art that had been trickling into American museums and galleries, but the shocking, experimental work that was reshaping the very definition of art.
On February 17, 1913, the International Exhibition of Modern Art opened at the 69th Regiment Armory at 68 Lexington Avenue, between 25th and 26th Streets. The location was perfect: a massive drill hall just two blocks from the heart of the Flatiron District and one block from Madison Square, in what is now the NoMad neighborhood. The armory, completed in 1906 and designed in the Beaux-Arts style by Hunt & Hunt, was itself a symbol of the neighborhood’s Gilded Age grandeur—but what happened inside would shatter that era’s artistic complacency forever.
The 1,400-work exhibition became almost a complete history of European Modernism, displaying works by Impressionists, Symbolists, Postimpressionists, Fauves, and Cubists alongside American artists. But it was the European avant-garde that stunned visitors. Marcel Duchamp’s Cubist painting “Nude Descending a Staircase, No. 2” was popularly described as “an explosion in a shingle factory.” Henri Matisse’s bold colors and distorted forms left viewers perplexed. Nearly 90,000 people came to see what one critic called “the future of art”—many leaving shocked, bewildered, or transformed.
This was rebellion on an unprecedented scale. For over a century, American artists had sought legitimacy by emulating European masters.
Now, suddenly, Americans were confronted with European art so radical it seemed to reject everything art had traditionally represented. The show challenged the fundamental assumption that art must be beautiful, recognizable, or even comprehensible. It was the first time the phrase “avant-garde” was used to describe painting and sculpture in America.
The cultural earthquake that began in that NoMad armory would reshape American art forever. The show’s impact on American collectors contributed to the founding of the Museum of Modern Art and the Whitney Museum. Progressive American artists like Georgia O’Keeffe, John Marin, and Edward Hopper—who made his very first sale at the Armory Show—felt liberated to pursue experimental paths. The Armory Show had accomplished what no previous rebellion had achieved: it freed American art from the need to seek European approval by showing that even Europeans had abandoned the academic traditions Americans were still trying to master.
The Neighborhood’s Legacy
The pattern is unmistakable: from the National Academy’s break from Trumbull to “The Eight” side-stepping the National Academy, from Macbeth’s American focus to 291 Gallery’s elevation of photography and European risk-takers, and finally to the Armory Show’s complete artistic revolution—this neighborhood has been the stage for every major rebellion in American art history. Each generation of artists found the previous generation’s rebels had become the new establishment, requiring yet another break toward artistic freedom.
Today, as you walk through NoMad and the Flatiron District, you’re traversing the geographic heart of American art’s evolution from European imitation to authentic American expression. The irony that Trumbull—painter of rebels who became an authoritarian—established would repeat itself again and again, until that final, explosive moment in 1913 when American art finally found the courage to chart its own course. In this neighborhood, artistic rebellion didn’t just happen—it became a tradition.
❧